Harry Potter and the HBP - includes SPOILERS!!! - Beyond Tiki

P PapeToaTane Member Salt Lake City, Utah Joined: Mar 19, 2005 Posts: 518	P PapeToaTane Posted posted on Fri, Aug 5, 2005 12:48 PM On 2005-08-05 10:07, Tikibelle wrote: Well, here’s another bone to chew on… Did Dumbledore have to die so that Harry would be able to stand on his own at the end? To be the true hero. Yeah, I think so. This was foreshadowed a bit when you juxtapose the two comments made before and after Harry and Dumbledore went into the cave after the horcrux. Before Harry left Ron and Hermione at Hogwarts (when he gave them the felix potion), they said to Harry "... be safe." He said he would..."I'll be with Dumbledore!" When Albus was weak from the potion, Harry helped him out of the cave and he said to Harry that he wasn't worried... "I'm with YOU!"

On 2005-08-05 10:07, Tikibelle wrote:
Well, here’s another bone to chew on…
Did Dumbledore have to die so that Harry would be able to stand on his own at the end? To be the true hero.

Yeah, I think so. This was foreshadowed a bit when you juxtapose the two comments made before and after Harry and Dumbledore went into the cave after the horcrux. Before Harry left Ron and Hermione at Hogwarts (when he gave them the felix potion), they said to Harry "... be safe." He said he would..."I'll be with Dumbledore!" When Albus was weak from the potion, Harry helped him out of the cave and he said to Harry that he wasn't worried... "I'm with YOU!"

Post #177559 by PapeToaTane on Fri, Aug 5, 2005 12:48 PM