Post #290401 by Mai Tai on Wed, Mar 7, 2007 6:58 PM

I have also tried both the silver and the gold, and have to say that Martin's rating as terrible is also very generous. We joked that these looked like giant cologne or aftershave bottles, and tasted about the same as well. After all, these are being marketed as a top shelf rum, but compare to a standard well rum at best. These will not be appearing in my home either.