Post #690604 by djmont on Mon, Aug 19, 2013 10:24 AM

I hate to be a contrarian -- actually, I don't :) -- but if one is looking for authenticity in their recipes, using a true pomegranate syrup as grenadine won't give it to you. Grenadine has been nothing more than dyed sugar water since before Prohibition. Makes me think it's unlikely that Don or Vic were using otherwise.