Post #710033 by Destro100 on Mon, Mar 3, 2014 6:08 PM

I like Buffalo Trace as well. It's a very solid bourbon for the price.

In general, you can't go wrong with the big guys - Knob Creek, Bulleit, or Makers.

Much depends on how you intend to use it and the flavors you seek. If you're mixing in craft cocktails, you may want something stronger or a bourbon made with a strong rye mash. If you're drinking straight, you may prefer a smoother wheat mash mix which can also be a tad sweeter unless you prefer a spicier finish - then you're back to a stronger rye flavor. Personally, I have come to appreciate the ones (Elijah, Elmer, and Evan Will Single Barrel )I mentioned as they tend to really surprise me with the complexity of flavors and amazing price point.

I just reread your post - I'm not sure how I missed the coke reference. To be honest - almost any decent bourbon will suffice - The coke will hide most of the subtleties of the bourbon. By all means, you should enjoy the drink any way ou like - I've taken enough heat for enjoying my tiki drinks from those not in the know. I will say, definitely start experimenting with a bit of bourbon with a touch of water (like a scotch) or even with one ice cube. Even better try a real straight-forward Old fashioned - some bitters and a sugar cube. You might like it.

[ Edited by: destro100 2014-03-03 18:11 ]