Post #769127 by RumScrummager on Fri, Sep 30, 2016 12:50 PM

What about El Dorado 12-year and Appleton Rare Blend (12-year)? The higher proof on the Appleton Rare Blend (86 proof) is higher than Appleton Reserve's lower 80 proof, and more in keeping with Kohala Bay's original 87.6 proof. Also, Appleton Rare Blend (12-year) is a darker liquid. In terms of proof alone, this would perhaps be the closest approximation. Smith & Cross is slightly too 'overproof' (114 proof) and may prove to be too overpowering in drinks where Kohala Bay shined.