Pearl Diver's Punch v. the Pearl Diver

which is better? what say ye?

I'd go with the Punch.

The 'Pearl Diver' tilts a little more toward the booze, which seems to downgrade the contribution of the Pearl Diver's Mix.

But having said that, these drinks don't do much for me. There's a pleasant texture from the Pearl's Mix, but the overall flavor profile is a vague slightly tart juice taste. The drink is just... kinda... there.