Post #227861 by Kanekila on Fri, Apr 21, 2006 10:33 AM

JB actually wrote that tune as album filler, and wrote it in about 10 minutes.

Now, one could say "well, sure... anyone could write THAT in 10 minutes," but one would be wrong.

A well written song that relates a good hook, a theme and a story, in three verses and under 3 minutes, and encapsulates it all in a nice, radio-friendly package is an art form. Now, weather or not one LIKES that particular art form is another thing all together.

A great story telling song will be a complete audio vignette, with appropriate soundtrack, excellent arrangement and editing and should leave the listener with a certain feeling after hearing it, like you feel after leaving the theater. And do it all in a compact and concise 3 minutes, or so.

I'm definitely not saying I love this tune. In fact, as a working musician, I'd be happy to not have to play it again. What I am saying is, comparing JB to Martin Denny or Drasnin, or Lyman is like comparing apples to star fruit (that come from real stars, in galaxies far, far away). It's a pointless endeavor, because they're sooooooo totally different, and meant for different audiences.

Personally, if I could write a pop tune right now in 10 minutes that a lot of people would hate, but a lot MORE would love, and be guaranteed that would sell millions of copies overnight, I'd do it in a frickin' heartbeat. Then, I'd buy an island somewhere in the South Pacific, drink Mai Tai's, and listen to hapa-haole Hawaiian, surf and Exotica music all day long.

But, that's just me. YMMV... :)