Tiki Central / Tiki Music
The Buffet Rant and what it means.
T
TikiMaxton
Posted
posted
on
Thu, May 16, 2002 3:19 PM
Please read this whole post before you get your dander up. If, when you're finished, your dander is still in need of an uprising, then so be it... I've been following the "What's wrong with Jimmy Buffet?" thread with some interest. If I had been the one who posted the original question, my impression of the respondants (and the group as a whole) would be that we're all a bunch of stuffy, closed-minded collectors who aren't in the least interested in having a good time (oh yeah, and we all hate lite beer). Now here's the interesting part: A. I agree with all the negative sentiments. Here's what I'm getting around to; what to these anti-Buffet sentiments say about us and our love of tiki culture (and not about our opinion of Jimmy Buffet's music)? For me I know exactly what it says: I'm a purist and I love creating immersive environments. The environments I create are usually fun and interesting, but I also like them to be authentic in every way possible (without affecting the fun and interesting part). Experiences are like flavors, I think: each one is interesting and distinct and they should be enjoyed as such. Yes, I freak when maple syrup gets on my sausage. It just ain't right. I like sausage and I like syrup but they belong in separate bites, dammit! In case anyone is wondering, yes, I am indeed on heavy medication right now, and thanks for asking. They say "alcahol may intensify the effect" like that's a BAD thing... |
W
woofmutt
Posted
posted
on
Thu, May 16, 2002 9:32 PM
I for one think the only way to eat breakfast sausage is with some maple syrup on it (and I like syrup on my cornbread too). I read the "What's wrong with Jimmy Buffet" messages and thought that most everyone presented good arguments as to why they don't care for the whole Parrot Head scene. If there's one thing Tiki Centralites are good at it's analyzing a topic to the finest degree. |
F
fatuhiva
Posted
posted
on
Fri, May 17, 2002 12:54 AM
True Tiki is a dimly lit thatched bar with glowing orbs hanging from the ceiling, Arthur Lyman vibraphone seeping through the air, colorful drinks served in ceramic tiki mugs, and dark wooden tikis peeking out from behind Monstera Delicosa leaves in the corner.. Jimmy Buffet is a lame Florida "tiki" bar which amounts to nothing more than a crappy patio with no thatch in sight, plastic chairs, beer served in plastic cups, bad "classic" rock on the PA, and drunk mullet-haired over-the-hill partyin' types trying to pretend it's a "lifestyle" |
B
Biotron2000
Posted
posted
on
Fri, May 17, 2002 8:40 AM
I had no idea what I was starting...I thought it was a fairly innocent question, but I'm kinda new here. |
T
tikifish
Posted
posted
on
Fri, May 17, 2002 11:05 AM
Maxton, you on Zyban too? Damn this is some crazy-ass stuff. Dry... Mouth.... Need... Mai Tai.... |
L
laney
Posted
posted
on
Mon, May 20, 2002 8:41 PM
If you all were going for "authentic" half the crap you probably own wouldn't be in your tiki bars. |
T
tikifish
Posted
posted
on
Tue, May 21, 2002 6:00 AM
I don't think anyone here told anyone else not to listen to Jimmy Buffet... they just said why THEY wouldn't listen to Jimmy Buffett. PS. Long live Jimmy's Buffet! |
TC
Tiki Chris
Posted
posted
on
Tue, May 21, 2002 7:28 AM
Apparent from the large number of postings on this topic, making fun of Jimmy Buffet & commenting on his non-tiki-ness make several Tiki Centralites feel overwhelmingly good! Perhaps you could present your argument pertaining to how Mr. Buffet does fit in w/ your authentic tiki & danish thingies. [I was going to end this post w/ a witty(?) comment about big sticks in asses but thought it too distasteful.] Tiki Chris [ Edited by: Tiki Chris on 2002-05-21 07:32 ] |
K
KokomoTikiBar&Grill
Posted
posted
on
Tue, May 21, 2002 7:59 AM
who cares what kind of drinks is served at jimmy buffets. mcdonalds say they are in the hamburger business and i know they aint got no freaking hamburgers there. so he isnt tiki, but hes got a hell of a lot going for him. his music is great, he enjoys life and he is filthy rich. alot more than i can say about myself. i enjoy life, but i am musically challenged and i aint got no money. tiki to me is about the bar, the drinks, statues, mask, mugs, pinups and music. but what you determine to be fun should also be included. people who rant and rave over the small things are people who are extremly jealous of others. aloha from Kokomo, Mississippi. pine trees and palms baby!!!!!!! |
T
Tiki_Bong
Posted
posted
on
Tue, May 21, 2002 9:04 AM
People, people! Can't we all just get along? The poster of the original message just asked why we bag on JB. The reason is, well.. we are a group of tiki freaks. JB does not fit in with our perception of such. If we were a group of Jimmy Buffett freaks things would be different. Does anyone really think most Jimmy Buffett-philes give a rats ass about exotica? As a guitarist, I think Frank Zappa is one of the best guitarist, composers, arrangers that ever fondled a fingerboard. But most people laugh at FZ. Oh, well. Now, on the count of 3, a big tiki group hug and kiss (no tongues!). |
TW
Trader Woody
Posted
posted
on
Tue, May 21, 2002 9:35 AM
What some Buffetteers don't seem to have grasped is that there is quite a chasm between their idea of Tiki & the Polynesian Pop idea. Nobody is saying that you must adhere to some sort of Tiki-Nazi purity law. People can mix and match as much as they want, but a whole lot of us just have no interest in crappy 80's faux-Tiki-Caribbean cheese. Who wants a t-shirt with an alligator wearing Blues-Brothers sunglasses Nobody minds what music people listen to when they sup their fogcutters (hell, I listen to far more guitar-noise than lounge), but people do have an interest in the detail of Tiki. Sadly what many To use the Jimmy's Buffet analogy, it's like the difference between a Crab leg po' boy and a cheap crab spread sandwich. Trader Woody |
TC
Tiki Chris
Posted
posted
on
Tue, May 21, 2002 9:47 AM
Buff-divers? Brillant! I had no idea your were such a wordsmith! [ Edited by: Tiki Chris on 2002-05-21 09:47 ] |
T
TikiMaxton
Posted
posted
on
Tue, May 21, 2002 3:30 PM
What's wrong with tongues?! Sorry, just hadda do that... The meds have worn off... :sheckymug: |
J
johntiki
Posted
posted
on
Tue, May 21, 2002 5:29 PM
My reason for trying to create an authentic tiki bar in my home is simple. I wasn't alive during the tiki heyday and I live about 1,000 miles from a good tiki bar - I'm recreating a place I've never physically been but have visited hundreds of times when listenening to Martin Denny,Les Baxter, etc. If I want to listen to Jimmy Buffet in a faux tropical setting all I need to do is hop in the car, drive 20 miles to Baltimore and take my choice of unhospitable, drunken frat boy bars. No thanks... If you want to be reminded of an exotic tiki paradise listen to exotica - if you want to recreate a night vomiting margaritas in a urine soaked men's room in Key West or losing consciousness in a grotesque port-a-pot in the parking lot of some concert venue - then crank up good ole' Jimmy!! :P Johntiki :drink: [ Edited by: johntiki on 2002-05-21 17:30 ] |
F
fatuhiva
Posted
posted
on
Tue, May 21, 2002 9:00 PM
"If you want to be reminded of an exotic tiki paradise listen to exotica - if you want to recreate a night vomiting margaritas in a urine soaked men's room in Key West or losing consciousness in a grotesque port-a-pot in the parking lot of some concert venue - then crank up good ole' Jimmy!! " HAHAHAHA That's a CLASSIC! |
S
Swanky
Posted
posted
on
Wed, May 22, 2002 6:44 AM
For most of us, the exotica of Martin Denny and the 40's-60's lounge and classic ploynesian music is as far away, romantic and mystical as the "little island in the Pacific." On the other hand, Jimmy Buffett is as close as the nearest college campus bar, or even closer. It's not just some knick-knacks we savor, but the exotic lands and attitudes that come with it. That's what brought ex-GI's to Polynesian bars and restaurants in NYC and Chicago, and elsewhere in the 50's, and that's what we crave and search out and try to recreate. I suppose there is a group among us that is more about Key West and Parrots than Maui and marimbas. But this whole thing was born of the first group. The second is late to the party. And the first group looks at the second as crashers. When one of the second group requests Buffett at the tiki bar, they are revealed. I'd say a good many don't hate Buffett, but they don't see his music as pertaining to the Polynesian Pop mythos. |
TM
tiki mick
Posted
posted
on
Wed, Dec 14, 2005 4:12 PM
|
P
pablus
Posted
posted
on
Thu, Dec 15, 2005 8:03 AM
After seeing an interview with the guy I can't say I hate him. He seems like a pretty genuine dude and understands he's not Martin Denny or the savior of Tiki or anything. Still wouldn't ever go to a concert unless I was jones'n real bad. But Flounder loves him and I like Flounder so... Kanekila is a fan, too, but he's from Wisconsin so... there you go. Jimmy lurked here for a while I'm told but we were big meanies to him. Jimmy, if you're reading this - there's still hope. |
T
tikiskip
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Dec 16, 2005 7:43 AM
Would someone please tell me what I like so I can go out and get it now. I don't care what you say about buffet, but diss'n people with sticks in their asses, Well that's just going too far! |
UT
Urban Tiki
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Dec 16, 2005 1:49 PM
To paraphrase one of my favorite quotes: Tiki is too important to be taken seriously. JB is cool. He ain't tiki, but he's got the tiki spirit. I wonder if some of the critics would hate tiki if they went into a tiki bar and there were a lot of drunken frat boys. Are people drunk on Mai Tais less obnoxious than people drunk on Margaritas? Loosen up. |
V
vegasvic
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Dec 16, 2005 2:42 PM
Wow, some threads never die. I've always found this one interesting in a social-experiment, human-observation kinda way. Yeah, yeah we all love Martin Denny and we all like to drink rum and hang out together blah, blah. But maybe -- just maybe, for this whole tiki/exotica movie we live in to be a little more interesting, we want - no, we need some kind of shared conflict, a villian, an antagonist to face off with our collective protagonist. Rocky-Apollo Creed, Red Sox-Yankees, Superman-Lex Luther, Metallica-Megadeth, whatever. Maybe Jimmy Buffet and the Parrotheads fill that gap for us? Or maybe I'm taking that screenwriting class way too seriously..... |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Dec 16, 2005 4:11 PM
Very well put! I also think it creates an opportunity to show wisdom and restraint by not joining in the fray. But since I've never been accused of having either, I'll share a few thoughts. I think I must have been in a cave through the '80s and '90s, because when I recently made an effort to delve into Buffett's 35+ year body of work, I did so without any idea that he was associated with the sorts of objectionable social "scenes" that keep getting mentioned here in relation to him (the classic one being a sort of archetypal crew of "drunken frat boys" who ruin tiki bars by demanding to hear "Cheeseburger in Paradise" then puking on the floor (have I got that right?)). So, I brought his music into my own "scene," so to speak, winnowing out what I regarded as the less substantial, "party" material, and finding that I liked much of what was left over. Countless songs evoking travel, adventure, and optimism. Respectful lyrical interweavings with the legacies of adventurers, storytellers, and entertainers of years gone by, from Mark Twain to Carmen Miranda. "Love songs" written to places -- cities, seas, cultural spheres. And generally these are the sorts of places that attract me (and I dare say, most of you): New Orleans; Brazil; the Caribbean islands; Tahiti; etc. Let others sing and write of alpine mountains; I get cold in such places. I've got a feeling some here on Tikicentral can relate to me on this, am I right? I'm just glad I went ahead and investigated the material and made up my own mind, rather than being dissuaded by the spiteful comments of others. It so happens my overall assessment is positive, but I would feel this way even if it were negative. I would like to recommend the same approach to anyone who is wondering what all the fuss is about. There are many ways to do this on the cheap. I used an old-fashioned one: the library system. So, if you still dislike Jimmy Buffett, you'll be able to say something intelligent like, "I prefer jazz" or "I'm not into the 'singer-songwriter' thing" or even just "I don't like his voice," instead of just reciting hateful caricatures of other people whose tastes differ from yours. |
P
pablus
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Dec 16, 2005 6:41 PM
On another positive vein - Jake Shimabukuro got on stage with him a few times and that's nothing but cool. Nice post, Thomas. Unfortunately this is also true: http://www.margaritaville.com/cafes.php Yecch. This doesn't conjure up any of the cool things his better songs that you mentioned do. |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Dec 16, 2005 8:31 PM
I'm of two minds on that, Pablus. When it comes to personal taste, I'm inclined to agree: I probably wouldn't fly to Jamaica or Cancun, for example, and go to Margaritaville. My impulse would certainly be to try to have a more unique experience generated by a combination of my own efforts and happenstance. Life tends to more interesting that way in my opinion, and I gather that you feel the same way. I can't say I look at the photos of those establishments and say, "Yecch," though. I see the results of risk-taking capital investment. I see payrolls with thousands of people earning paychecks, health insurance, and the like (I've never created a job opportunity for a Jamaican, and probably never will -- I am inclined to salute those who do). I see enterprises which pay taxes to the jurisdictions in which they are located, which help fund schools, police departments, and the like. I see a brand which seeks to promise a high level of service (decent, safe food; clean restrooms; etc.) and will suffer if it fails to deliver these things. I think these things are morally good, simply put, and in a way that does not depend on whether or not I personally share the aesthetic sense of the establishments (which, on the whole, I do not). Pablus, this might seem obsequious, but here goes nonetheless. I'm relatively new here, and haven't had the pleasure of meeting you or any of the folks here in person yet. However I have read in recent weeks of your pain at losing a friend and brother in music, your global travels, and your professional recording endeavors. As insecure as this might seem on my part, I'll not hide that I felt honored by your response to my post. I know that sounds a bit over the top, but it's pretty much how I feel right now, so there it is. |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Dec 16, 2005 8:56 PM
Kind of related to the above, there is a very entertaining series of 5 brief dispatches from a guy travelling the length of Baja California, in slate.com. His preference for the pristine over the commercialized will strike a familiar chord. His encounter with Cabo is particularly entertaining in this regard. It's like a Mon. - Fri. diary, starting with Mon.: -- T. |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Dec 16, 2005 11:10 PM
This was prompted by this, from Sabu the Coconut Boy, in another thread: Tangentially, for those who find the devotion of Parrotheads a bit cultish, and are thus inclined to suspect that Jimmy Buffett might be the antichrist, it bears noting that his birthday is none other than Dec. 25, and this upcoming one will be his 60th. By all means let us hang no graven images of Jimmy Buffett this Christmas season (and avoid playing his Christmas album, which is a good idea in any case), lest we hasten the arrival of the age of darkness. One of the early signs of which will be announcement that Margaritaville is launching a hostile takeover of Trader Vic's, and Wall Street approves... |
K
Kawentzmann
Posted
posted
on
Sat, Dec 17, 2005 1:38 AM
Absolutely YES! KK |
I
ikitnrev
Posted
posted
on
Sat, Dec 17, 2005 10:38 AM
I came across these lyrics, to a David Allen Coe song titled 'The Jimmy Buffer Song' Now Jimmy's moved to Malibu with all those other stars So don't tell me I sound like Jimmy Buffet
|
T
tikigik
Posted
posted
on
Mon, Apr 17, 2006 5:10 PM
pablus wrote:
And Martin Denny, as well. I know JB isn't Exotica (I tend Jimmy B. In other words, I'd slowly work them from what they KNOW to |
L
lanikai
Posted
posted
on
Mon, Apr 17, 2006 6:48 PM
I have tried to give Jimmy Buffett's stuff a chance. But fer eg; whenever I hear that female chorus join in; and his lyrics are overly simplistic and cute, (sometimes bordering on the infantile) rhyming anything just for the sake of rhyming often. "zucchini fettuchini". His "Changes in attitude" is a rip off of the old "Sonora's Death Row." listen to Leo Kottke's rendition. How bout this: A web site (http://tinyurl.com/zcupd) that tries to understand the attraction of Buffet and his cult generously explains: "Jimmy Buffet's music can be best described as adult nursery rhymes celebrating drunkenness, laziness and promiscuity" "It can aptly be categorized as yuppie muzak. The ubiquitous xylophone and maracas create a nauseating faux island music experience" "This clown and his band are nothing more than a wedding/bar band that got lucky and found a nitch of idiots with more money that taste. The fans often refer to themselves as Parrot Heads who adorn themselves in silly straw hats, fake Hawaiian shirts, tight Khaki shorts, sandals and those sun glasses with the strings attached." I listened to pirate at forty just now. and his appropriation of carribean, marimba and mexican musical elements and motifs to flavor his songs that damned near sound all the same, makes ya realize; OK, he originally composed ditties for Disney and had the flash: "Hey! I could create a cult following darn near what the grateful dead had". (or rather: "Dern neyar whaut thuh guh-rate fuwol deyad heyud". Oh. and his margaritaville tequila features some of the most pretentious copy ever written on a label on a bottle of any kind since adam and eve. ("hey. Why doesn't anyone wanna leave Margaritaville? Cuz ya haveta go through Hangovertown to do it.") His forgettable, snore inducing sllloooowww throwaway songs shanghai your brain and force it to board the boredom boat and float to somnambulistic oblivion. The only recourse is to run screaming to any other brand of tequila but his, to wash away the K-mart level musical experience. Other than that, I like him. [ Edited by: lanikai 2006-04-17 18:54 ] |
P
pablus
Posted
posted
on
Tue, Apr 18, 2006 3:00 AM
LOL. Just grab the kini-kini and start swinging. Mahalo, lanikai. |
K
Kanekila
Posted
posted
on
Tue, Apr 18, 2006 12:56 PM
C'mon, Lanikai. Stop holding back -- tell us how you REALLY FEEL! :) |
BM
bb moondog
Posted
posted
on
Tue, Apr 18, 2006 1:36 PM
I am so happy someone into tiki other than me disses this one trick pony! his music is LARRY WELK EXOTICA; ya know whats funny, though? his books aren't half-bad & I think he actuyally is in on his own joke...yet the momentum & the $$$ make it impossible to deny. Lets just say I own a TON of Martin Denny and not one Buffett |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Thu, Apr 20, 2006 9:23 PM
Jake Shimabukuro is apparently again featuring prominently in JB's current tour. Impressive stuff. Re. some of the above comments, yeah, some of his stuff is abominable. I only like the good stuff. I think the US military should use "Cheeseburger..." as part of psy-ops when trying to flush terrorists out of their hiding places. Just crank it, on a continuous tape loop... "Far side of the World," "Beach House on the Moon," "Off to See the lizard" etc. have some nice, refreshing stuff. None of it ever got any radio play, which is probably a plus nowadays. Anyway, to each his own. I hope no one's forming a conclusion based on some three songs, e.g. M'ville, Why don't we get drunk, and Cheeseburger. Jeez, if that's all there was to him I'd revile him too. Well, M'ville is a cute piece of work, but a victim of its own success. Driving a rental car around Naples, FL a few months ago, I tuned into one of those ultra-saccharine easy-listening stations for older folks. They played a version of Margaritaville that was all strings, like Muzak for the lobby of an old folks' home. I thought, "yes, this is where it's headed, isn't it!" But ya know, it was actually pretty good... Or at least, fitting to the environment. I cranked it and enjoyed the ride. |
K
Kanekila
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 10:33 AM
JB actually wrote that tune as album filler, and wrote it in about 10 minutes. Now, one could say "well, sure... anyone could write THAT in 10 minutes," but one would be wrong. A well written song that relates a good hook, a theme and a story, in three verses and under 3 minutes, and encapsulates it all in a nice, radio-friendly package is an art form. Now, weather or not one LIKES that particular art form is another thing all together. A great story telling song will be a complete audio vignette, with appropriate soundtrack, excellent arrangement and editing and should leave the listener with a certain feeling after hearing it, like you feel after leaving the theater. And do it all in a compact and concise 3 minutes, or so. I'm definitely not saying I love this tune. In fact, as a working musician, I'd be happy to not have to play it again. What I am saying is, comparing JB to Martin Denny or Drasnin, or Lyman is like comparing apples to star fruit (that come from real stars, in galaxies far, far away). It's a pointless endeavor, because they're sooooooo totally different, and meant for different audiences. Personally, if I could write a pop tune right now in 10 minutes that a lot of people would hate, but a lot MORE would love, and be guaranteed that would sell millions of copies overnight, I'd do it in a frickin' heartbeat. Then, I'd buy an island somewhere in the South Pacific, drink Mai Tai's, and listen to hapa-haole Hawaiian, surf and Exotica music all day long. But, that's just me. YMMV... :) |
L
lanikai
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 12:08 PM
No, that's me too. |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 12:58 PM
Wonder if you have an opinion on such songs as Coast of Carolina; Altered Boy; Lucky Stars; Happily Ever After (Now and Then); Remittance Man; Cowboy in the Jungle; Quietly Making Noise; Boomerang Love; That's What Living is to Me; They Don't Dance Like Carmen No More. Songs like these are why I find Buffett a worthwhile artist on the whole. His many critics here on TC tend to cite the same few songs of his from 30 years ago. Fair enough, but it does make for kind of a circumscribed and repetitive discussion. It's fine to form an opinion of an artist based on a tiny sample (say 1 or 2 percent) of his or her body of work -- our time is limited, and sometimes it's good to just say, "I don't think that's for me" and move on, leaving the other 98-99% of the stones unturned. But if, I say if, in all honesty you can only name, say, three or four songs by a songwriter who has recorded many hundreds over the years, it might not hurt to temper your negative rants with the acknowledgment that you are basing your criticism on a superficial understanding of the whole. |
L
lanikai
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 1:50 PM
don't get pissed. You missed the gist. |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 2:44 PM
|
L
lanikai
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 3:13 PM
I could have been counted as one of those. and I may get equally enthusiastic at a friend's local punk band, da merrie monarch hula festival, or Shimabukuro nite at da local sushi place...
...inexplicably, an image of the Hell's Angels' Toys for tots run comes to mind. NOT that there's anything wrong with that. Some of my friends are riders with that m.c..
Got the same hat on too, when I comment on the JB phenom. It's just fun to debate it... Re; the other songs, just figured his stuff would be along the same lines as da old stuff, esp, with those overly cute gimmicky song titles: Altered boy. Quietly Making Noise. Happily Ever After Now and Then. Suppose I should fire up mp3.com or itunes store and give it a chance... lemme swallow a few shots of cabo wabo first... cheers! [ Edited by: lanikai 2006-04-21 15:14 ] |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 3:26 PM
I totally identify with this. In fact, it's one of the reasons I move at such a glacial pace in redoing our home with "immersive" tropical/tiki decor. I have such elaborate, perfectionistic visions of what I want, it's hard to actually get it done. (But I will, and it'll show up on TC in due time.) I wonder if a touch of obsessiveness isn't a bit more common among us here on TC than in the general population. Harrah's-Laughlin has just put in a nice "Beach Cafe" with repros of vintage travel posters (e.g. Tahiti), movie posters (Endless Summer, Elvis's Hawaii movies, etc.), a tiki carving or two, etc. Overwhelmingly Pacific / Californian / surfing / Hawaiian-Polynesian ... but then I saw a minority of Caribbean stuff mixed in with it, even a parrot or two if I'm not mistaken, and couldn't help explaining to my wife why I found that to be a very regretful negative mark on the decor. I also can't stand seeing wires -- electrical chords and the like. We recently went to a pretty nice bar, but the electrical chord from a TV on the wall just looped lazily across the wall on its way to the electrical socket. I spent about five minutes explaining how much this ruined the aesthetics of the place, until I saw my wife looking at me as if to say, "I wonder if there is a name for this sort of syndrome..." Well, I digress, but I just wanted to express my agreement with what TikiMaxton wrote. And yes, Parrot Heads tend not to share this obsessive streak. Pirates, tikis, parrots, all mixed together -- no, it's all like that electrical chord on the wall, and I just can't get over it, it bothers me so!... Ahem, just kidding. |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 3:29 PM
Likewise, cheers to you, lanikai. |
T
tikigik
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 4:41 PM
lanikai wrote:
Failing to see a problem here. As I approach retirement, I'm
Okay, now, CONFESS! How do you REALLY feel?
Oh, okay, as long as you don't COMPLETELY hate him. :wink: [ Edited by: tikigik 2006-04-21 16:42 ] |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 5:20 PM
I have yet another thought on the matter (after which I think I should go cold turkey on this topic for a while...). I think when people have a strong fondness for something, they get very particular about delineations and often strongly dislike stuff that is "close" to it but not "the real thing." Some examples: I know a guy who's a big Allman Brothers fan. He hates it when people put them in the category of "southern rock" and associate them with bands like Lynard Skynard. The distinction is very important to him. The Allmans are much more associated with the richness of the blues tradition, he insists (and rightly so, I say). But anyway, as an Allmans fan, he's neutral regarding, say, Bach, but strongly dislikes Skynard. It's easy to imagine a diehard water skier in, say, Florida, who is entirely neutral regarding ice fishing ("seems OK, but it sure isn't my thing!"), but hates jet-skis ("they're awful! I hate 'em!"). Again, it's the thing that's "close, but not the real thing" that becomes the object of derision. Any number of other examples come to mind. It's easy to imagine a Sinatra fan in the early '60s who was neither positive nor negative regarding polka music, but strongly disliked Bobby Darin ("trying to emulate Sinatra! A faker!..."). Again, the "proximal" thing gets the disdain in this sort of scenario. Some of the passionate feelings regarding JB's stuff, which is often labelled "trop-rock" and is associated with the southeast and gulf coast, on the part of TCers seems to me manifest this process as well. Some sayings come to mind: "Good fences make good neighbors" ; "Familiarity breeds contempt" ; etc. |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 5:55 PM
One more thing! Once in a while in this topic I catch a whiff of geographical/social prejudice. There is an undertone of disdain, occasionally, for the southeast, southern accents, etc. Sometimes it even goes from "undertone" to "overtone" in the form of over-the-top caricature. I'm no P.C. cop, and think we all should have thick skins and be able to endure a bit of regional stereotyping now and then (I should know, I'm originally from New Jersey), but I figured it merited a mention anyway. JB has a southern accent. It's not fake. He grew up in Mobile, AL. He is a very successful white southerner, and does not appear to suffer psychological guilt over this. This probably overstates the matter a bit, but sometimes it seems that for some folks, this is his gravest sin. Prejudice does take many forms. My opinion regarding the south is pretty simple: it's warmer there than it is in New Jersey. |
L
lanikai
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 6:03 PM
Hey! you were supposed ta.... |
L
lanikai
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 6:11 PM
Weyull, pardnuh, thayut wuz me. It's just that... a southern accent? In tropicrock? dass a crock! and for us here on da lava rock, we get enuff of the southern fried rock. |
T
Thomas
Posted
posted
on
Fri, Apr 21, 2006 6:29 PM
Well, "trop-rock" is a vague term -- the Beach Boys' "Kokomo" fits in there too. Heck, so do the Pina Colada song, and the Love Boat theme, for all I know. But it is strongly associated with Florida as well as something called "Gulf and Western" (country music associated with the gulf coast, thus the boating and fishing lifestyle of that region to a large extent). A lot of goofy mush has come out of this sub-genre, but also it's often interesting to see country music encounter, and mix with, Caribbean stuff like steel drums and the like. I repeat: a lot of goofy mush ... but also some pretty nice stuff has emerged from this encounter. Mainstream country music, broadly speaking, not having been known for being particularly "multicultural" or "integrated," encounters the Caribbean. I dunno, I find it a musical twist that merits a listen now and then, and I personally find that a lot of it "travels" well, that is, works in other tropical/coastal settings other than the one from which it emerged (a bit like how reggae is very popular in Hawaii, the Philippines, etc.). But that's just one man's opinion. |